The Presence in the MidstQuakerInfo.com
Google
 
Web quakerinfo.com
Your online source for information about the Religious Society of Friends (Quakers).

Home
Articles
Friends Christian Renewal
Feedback
Finding Quakers
Quaker Books & Video
Quaker Art Prints
What's New
Publishing at QuakerInfo.com
Latest Newsletter
About Us
Bio
Calendar of Yearly Meetings
Privacy Policy
Facebook logo QuakerInfo.com
on Facebook

PicoSearch


Search Bill Samuel's
Web Sites




Except for a few reprinted old documents, articles on this site are copyrighted by the author, and may not be reprinted without permission. You are, however, free to link to any article or page on this site without prior permission although it's nice to know who's linking to us.

Bill Samuel, August 4, 2002
Bill Samuel
Webservant
QuakerInfo.com

Barclay's Catechism and
Confession of Faith

A review by Bill Samuel
Originally published April 1, 2001 at Suite101.com

Robert Barclay played a key role among early Friends. Better educated than most, with part of his education from Calvinists and part from Jesuits, he became the leading theologian of the Quaker movement. While a number of early Friends wrote doctrinal works, Barclay was the one who wrote more systematic theological treatises which stand to the present day as the most definitive expressions of early Quaker belief.

Barclay is best known for his Apology for the True Christian Divinity, which has remained in print since its first publication more than three centuries ago. However, his earlier work, A Catechism and Confession of Faith, was also widely used among Friends for hundreds of years.

Unlike the Apology, this earlier work had been out of print for a long time. Consequently, even its existence has not been widely known among contemporary Friends. But within the last few months, it has once again become readily available. It is now available in two ways:
  1. In print form edited in modern English by Dean Freiday and Arthur O. Roberts (Barclay Press, 2001)
  2. Online, in the original English of the Third Edition (1673).
It is no coincidence that both the modern English and original language versions became available at around the same time. The original language version was put online by Friends concerned that the modern English version would inevitably change to some degree the original meaning. They contend that 17th century English is understandable by contemporary English speakers, and thus a modern English version is undesirable. Personally, I think it is good to have both approaches available.

Both the catechism and confession formats were very common in Barclay's day. Usually the confession was placed first, but Barclay reversed that on the grounds that, "It is more orderly to begin with easier and more readily understood things and then progress to those that are more difficult and involved."

The catechism is a question and answer format where the answers are all passages of scripture. The confession is a summary of doctrines, using largely Biblical language but with some editorial changes for appropriate flow. Together, these present the faith understandings of Friends through use of the scripture, and directly counter accusations against Friends through appeals to scripture.

Barclay, who was just 24 when this work was first published, had a little fun with it. He took the name originally given Friends in derision, Quakers, and used it in several of the questions in the catechism. He thus uses the scriptural references to people trembling at the words of God to prove the soundness of what others criticized Friends for.

Barclay adds two things to the catechism and confession. The first is a discussion of the logical steps to reasoning together about what the Christian faith means. The second is a tearing apart of some key sections of the Westminster Confession, the most widely used confession of his day. These show the workings of his keen mind.

I found that the editors of the modern English version did a remarkably good job of making the work very easily readable. In addition to updating Barclay's own words, they substituted the New Revised Standard Version for the King James. In many instances, they also put an additional modern translation in footnotes.

The editors think that the modern English version is well suited as a discussion resource and study guide for those wishing to deepen their understanding of Quaker beliefs and perspectives. I agree with them, and feel it is much better suited to this than the better known Apology. Those wondering whether the change in language may have altered the meaning can refer to the online original language version and reach their own conclusions.
© by Bill Samuel. Do not reprint in whole or in part without prior permission of the author, except for limited quoting in accordance with "fair use" principles. You are welcome to link to this page.
Enter email address
to join newsletter
mailing list


Big Selection
of Quaker Books

Quaker and general books,
videos and other products.




Recommended Books: see all items
A Living Faith: An Historical and Comparative Study of Quaker Beliefs
Cover imageWilmer Cooper, founding Dean of Earlham School of Religion, provides an historical look at the beliefs of Friends (Quakers). Includes study questions.
Prayer: Finding the Heart's True Home
Cover imageRichard J. Foster. Describes 21 types of Christian prayer. Harper San Francisco, 1992. 288 pages.
Journal of George Fox
Cover imageThe auto- biography of the founder of the Religious Society of Friends (Quakers).
Celebration of Discipline
Cover image20th Anniversary Edition of Richard J. Foster's million- selling work on Christian spiritual disciplines.
Imagination & Spirit: A Contemporary Quaker Reader
Cover imageA selection of excerpts from 15 contemporary Quaker authors who reached the mainstream market. See review.

Recommended Art Print: see all prints


The Peaceable Kingdom
by Edward Hicks
29 in. x 23 in.

List of Articles . About Us . QuakerInfo.com Home . Quaker Books . Quaker Art Prints

QuakerInfo.com Newsletter

We publish an infrequent email newsletter that gives updates on the site plus news of Quakers. Your email address will be held in strict confidence. Subscribe by putting your email address in the box below and clicking on Subscribe. You will need to respond to a confirmation email. If you control spam by having an approved list of addresses from which you receive email, be sure to put webservant@quakerinfo.com on your approved list. NOTE: If you get a “subscription submittal failure” in response to a subscription attempt, the usual reason is that you are already subscribed.

Document last modified on Saturday, 22-Oct-2005 20:53:35 EDT